For my eighteenth birthday, my older sisters proposed that the three of us treat ourselves to stone hearts. Rachel and Helen would pay for mine, as a present.

Initially, I was on the fence. My boyfriend Logan and I were in the midst of a protracted negotiation about what would happen to our relationship, once we left for different colleges in August (mine in Vermont, his in Minnesota). I felt like this was a delicate time that required flexibility, rather than rigidity.

“How about we get matching tattoos instead?” I proposed.

Helen rolled her eyes, and Rachel said, “Come on, Pooper!” (Short for Party Pooper, but also, something they had called me since forever, because I hadn’t gotten potty trained until I was nearly four).

Then Logan decided, instead of staying together but seeing other people, it would be less complicated if we simply broke up, and moreover, if we broke up a month before leaving for college to give ourselves maximum recovery time. In order to have things be as clean as possible, he suggested we cut off all contact. Then he immediately blocked me on all media.

So I decided fuck it, and agreed to get hearts of stone.

***

On my birthday, we had a small family dinner. After I blew out the candles on my banana cake with cream cheese frosting, my parents said, “You girls have fun!” They thought we were going clubbing. To facilitate this ruse, we all wore our nightclub garb. Normally my mother would give me a hard time about wearing a skirt that short and Rachel a hard time because “How does anyone see your beautiful face, with all that make-up?” But my parents were being careful with all three of us lately: me, because of Logan; Rachel, because she’d called off her engagement with Steve; Helen, because Helen’s awful haircut was clearly a cry for help, and my parents didn’t know how to handle such a cry other than to tell her to go have fun.

It felt like we were in costume, our clothes but also our docile faces.

We hopped in Rachel’s hatchback and drove to the Mineral Crone. According to Rachel, this crone had the best Yelp reviews.

When the crone opened the door, I was surprised. She was a little plump, with a soft, pretty face. She looked thirty, tops. Nothing about her spoke “crone.”

Rachel informed her we were here for our heart-removal and stone-replacement appointments. The crone said “Naturally,” and offered us mineral water or tea made out of ground pumice.

 Rachel said that she would like to go first, and that she would like her heart replaced with rose quartz.

The crone shook her head immediately. “Did you see something about rose quartz on TikTok?” she scoffed, making Rachel blush. That’s not how it works, she told us. We couldn’t just order a particular stone. She handed us each clipboards, pens, and questionnaires. “That’s how we’ll determine what stone is right for each of you,” she said.

I looked at the first question and wanted to ask my sisters for input, but the crone shook her head again, and directed us to different corners of the room. “Fill them out silently,” she said, and made the lip-zipping motion.

What smell brings you the most comfort?

When you look into the blue center of a fire, what image do you see?

What topping do you prefer on toast?

What human feeling would you most miss?

That fourth question made me raise my hand. The crone, annoyed, beckoned me to come forward and whisper in her ear.

“Will having a stone heart interfere with my studies?” I asked her.

“On the contrary,” she whispered back. “You will find a new focus and pleasure in intellectual labors. Many recipients of hearts of stone end up pursuing the so-called life of the mind. Like myself,” she added, and pointed at a framed doctoral degree on the wall.

My sister Helen looked up, and though she couldn’t hear what the crone had said, her anxious expression dissipated. For a long time the only sound in the room was the faint scratching of our pens.

I was pleased when the crone matched me with obsidian. I remembered that stone from middle-school science: how it could look smooth, like black glass, or cracked, like something burned in a furnace.

My new heart is impregnable, though at times, I admit, I miss its human beat and lurch.

Pin It on Pinterest